2025: A Year of Theocratic Theater and Truths
Subscribe for updates: Leave this field empty if you're human: By Mike Smithgall | Jan 1, 2026 | Atheistville | Heathen Hotline: (224) 307-5435 If you watched the news in 2025, you could be forgiven for thinking we were witnessing the triumphant return of theocracy. The visuals were certainly designed to make you think that….
If you watched the news in 2025, you could be forgiven for thinking we were witnessing the triumphant return of theocracy. The visuals were certainly designed to make you think that. We saw smoke. We saw fire. We saw a giant, projected head booming commands at the citizenry.
We watched a sitting Defense Secretary attempt to rebrand the military as the “Department of War” while reciting the Lord’s Prayer over fighter jets. We watched the state of Louisiana use the heavy hand of the government to mandate religious texts in public school classrooms. We watched politicians who built their careers on “free speech” suddenly pivot to labeling political dissent as terrorism.
It was loud. It was aggressive. It was terrifying.
However, if you know the story of The Wizard of Oz, you know that the louder the projection, the smaller the man behind the curtain usually is.
When you strip away the pyrotechnics and look at the hard data, 2025 wasn’t the year the Religious Right took over. It was the year they realized they have already lost. The aggression we are seeing isn’t a display of strength. It is the panic of a movement that knows it is sliding into irrelevance.
The Demographics of Panic
To understand the political theater of the last twelve months, you have to look at the numbers the politicians are looking at. We aren’t just seeing a gradual decline in religious affiliation. We are seeing a cliff.
Recent data indicates a massive 17-point drop over the last decade in Americans who claim religion is important to their daily lives. That is not a statistical error. That is a cultural sea change. It suggests that millions of people are looking at what is being offered in the pews and politely, or perhaps not so politely, declining.
Sociologists have long studied secularization, but recent research from 2025 gives us a clearer model of how this happens. It is being called the “Zombie Church” phenomenon. Religion tends to die in a specific three-step sequence.
- Participation: People stop showing up physically.
- Importance: They stop caring mentally or spiritually.
- Belonging: They finally drop the label.

Right now, the Religious Right is in a panic because they are watching the “Participation” numbers freefall. They know the pews are empty. They know the youth groups are shrinking. They know the tithes are drying up.
This context is vital. When a religion has the hearts of the people, it doesn’t need to force its way onto classroom walls. It doesn’t need to pass laws like Louisianaโs H.B. 71 to mandate scripture in schools. You only resort to the blunt force of the state when you have lost the culture. You only mandate prayer when people have stopped praying voluntarily.
When “Bodily Autonomy” Became a Prop
If the demographics revealed their weakness, the hypocrisy of 2025 revealed their moral bankruptcy. This year, the mask didn’t just slip; it fell off entirely.
The most glaring example occurred in Florida. For years, we have heard arguments regarding the “sanctity of life” and the state’s right to intervene in medical decisions concerning pregnancy. The argument was always that the state has a moral obligation to override personal choice for a “higher good.”
Then came the measles outbreaks.
Suddenly, the same political apparatus that enforces strict abortion bans discovered the absolute sanctity of “bodily autonomy.” We heard the Surgeon General of Florida invoke “God’s will” to argue that the state could not mandate vaccines for school children.
This creates a dizzying logical contradiction. The state claimed the authority to force a woman to carry a pregnancy to term against her will but claimed it lacked the authority to require a proven shot to stop a preventable disease. They ended up defending freedom for viruses while denying it for women.
It revealed a hard truth. “Bodily autonomy” is not a principle for this movement. It is a prop. It is a rhetorical device they pick up when it is useful for their base and drop the moment it interferes with their theology.
The Aesthetic of War and the Sermon on the Peace
Perhaps nothing captured the spirit of 2025 better than the spectacle of Pete Hegseth and his “Department of War” rebranding.
Hegseth released a video reciting the Lord’s Prayer over a montage of military imagery. Fighter jets. Soldiers. Weapons. All culminating in a logo for a “Department of War.” It was a deliberate fusion of American military might with Christian iconography.
This is Christian Nationalism in its purest visual form. It attempts to borrow the perceived power of the military to prop up a fading religious authority.
However, for those actually familiar with the text they claim to follow, the irony is blinding. The Christian New Testament is explicitly non-militaristic in its core teachings. In the Sermon on the Mount, the foundational text of Christian ethics, the beatitude is specific.
“Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God.” (Matthew 5:9)
It does not say “Blessed are the warmongers.” Furthermore, regarding public displays of pietyโlike reciting prayers over PR videosโthe text is even more cutting.
“And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by others.” (Matthew 6:5)
By wrapping the machinery of war in the language of faith, figures like Hegseth aren’t elevating their politics. They are dragging their deity down into the mud of partisan violence. They are engaging in exactly the kind of performative theater that their own holy book condemns.
The Doomsday Clock That Doesnโt Tell Time
Beyond the politics, 2025 was a bad year for prophecy.
We witnessed yet another “Rapture” panic, this one scheduled for September 24th. Social media was flooded with warnings. Hashtags trended. The faithful prepared to be whisked away, leaving the rest of us to deal with the traffic.
Then Tuesday happened. Then Wednesday happened. The sun came up. The earth continued its rotation.
This might seem funny to an outsider, but these moments matter. Every time a doomsday prediction fails, the spell breaks for a few more people.
In the Hebrew Bible, the test for a prophet was rigorous. Deuteronomy 18:22 lays it out clearly.
“If what a prophet proclaims in the name of the Lord does not take place or come true, that is a message the Lord has not spoken. That prophet has spoken presumptuously, so do not be alarmed.”
According to their own scripture, a failed prediction isn’t just a miscalculation. It is proof that the speaker does not speak for God. When you wrap your politics or your predictions in the cross, and then reality humiliates you, you lose the one thing religion claims to own: moral and truth-telling authority.
The God of the Gaps is Shrinking
While theocrats spent the year fighting culture wars, the secular foundation of society continued to hold.
One of the oldest lies told about atheists and secularists is that without God, everything is permissible. The argument goes that without a divine policeman in the sky, humans will devolve into chaos.
2025 proved otherwise. In fact, we spent much of the year discussing the biological and evolutionary roots of morality. We know now that we don’t need a 2,000-year-old book to know that hurting people is wrong. Morality is an evolutionary trait rooted in empathy, cooperation, and the survival advantage of working together. We are moral because we are social primates, not because we are afraid of hell.
We also saw the “God of the Gaps” continue to shrink. This is the theological concept that God resides in the pockets of our ignorance. Thunder used to be the voice of God; now it is meteorology. Plague used to be a demon; now it is a virus.
Every time science advances, the territory religion claims dominion over gets smaller. It never expands. It only retreats. While the Religious Right offered thoughts, prayers, and performative bans, the secular world continued to look for solutions that actually work in reality.
๐ง Listen to the full episode on the podcast
The Long Middle
So, where does that leave us?
It leaves us in the “Long Middle.” This is the uncomfortable period between the breaking of the old order and the establishment of the new one.
The noise we heard in 2025 wasn’t the sound of a movement on the rise. It was the death rattle of a worldview that knows its time is up.
My goal is not to wipe religion off the map. I value my freedom of conscience too much to deny you yours. If I want the right not to believe, I must defend your right to believe. But I want a government that is neutral. I want a classroom that is honest. I want a public square where the best idea wins, not the one with the loudest megaphone.
When faith has to be pushed on people by the state, when it requires laws to force it into schools and threats to silence its critics, it stops looking like salvation. It starts looking like authoritarianism.
Don’t mistake volume for victory. The curtain has been pulled back. We know there is no wizard. There is just a nervous movement pulling levers, hoping we don’t notice the fire has gone out.
What do you think? Was 2025 a show of force or a show of fear? Leave a comment below.
Mike Smithgall is the creator and host of Atheistville, a YouTube and podcast series exploring atheism, deconversion, and secular life through real conversation. He believes belief should be personal, not political, and uses Atheistville to connect people across faith and nonbelief through curiosity and respect.
Author Archive | Tagged Posts | YouTube | Website | Podcast | Heathen Hotline: (224) 307-5435
