Breakfast With a Heathen EP6: Created for Hell? | Church Taxes, The Historical Jesus & Deconstruction Loneliness
This episode explores the unsettling theological issues surrounding an all-knowing God and the implications for humanity’s fate. Discussions include whether churches should retain tax-exempt status based on community contributions, historical comparisons of Jesus, and personal challenges in leaving religion. Viewer questions further enhance the dialogue.
In this episode, we tackle the dark theological implications of an all-knowing God: If the outcome is already known, did God create humanity just to send most of us to hell? We also dive into the heated debate over whether churches should lose their tax-exempt status if they fail to contribute tangibly to their communities.
Later, we analyze the “Telephone Game” of history regarding the existence of Jesus compared to figures like Alexander the Great, and address the personal side of leaving religion, from overcoming the guilt of enjoying secular music to the isolation of losing friends and family during deconstruction. Finally, we answer a listener’s concern about whether you need a “goth” aesthetic to fit in as a Satanist.
💬 Viewer Question
“If the U.S. government mandated that churches must donate a specific percentage of their income to local charities to keep their tax-exempt status, do you think most churches would comply or close their doors?”
Read the Q&A Highlights
In this episode, I’m coming to you just hours before jumping on a plane for a month-long trek through Asia. I’m leaving a freezing Chicago to head for the heat of Thailand and Japan with nothing but a backpack and a loose plan to “build my wings on the way down.”
But before I go, we have some great listener questions to tackle—ranging from the economics of the church to the “costume” of rebellion.
Q: “Why aren’t we taxing the church?”
(Asked by Espresso Asana)
The Heathen’s Take: This is the default question for many atheists, and honestly, I am conflicted. On one hand, I understand the logic that we don’t tax gifts. If you give a homeless person $10, we don’t tax that transaction. It’s charity.
But then you see a church with a hundred-thousand-dollar sound system and a pastor driving a luxury car that his parishioners could never afford, and the “charity” argument starts to crumble.
I remember back when I was a financial advisor in my 20s. A senior advisor took me to a small, not particularly wealthy part of town to meet a client who was a pastor. This man had $500,000 in his church retirement fund. I remember thinking, “How?”
In the mortgage world, I’ve seen pastors claim thousands of dollars a month in “housing expenses”—money that comes to them tax-free, while the rest of us pay for our mortgages with taxed income. When a church stops being a small community gathering and starts becoming a massive, untaxed corporation selling Jesus, it feels less like charity and more like corruption.
Q: “Do you believe Jesus actually existed?”
The Heathen’s Take: It is almost impossible to get unbiased information on this because the internet is flooded with apologetics.
Here is where I land: Do I believe in a magical figure who walked on water and had immediate, worldwide fame? Absolutely not. There are no contemporary records of him. No government documents, no historians writing about him while he was alive.
However, could there have been a preacher in the Middle East who had a small following? Sure. Just like a random preacher in Nebraska might have a following today. I’m willing to give the benefit of the doubt that a person existed, but the “Jesus” we know today is a legend that evolved over centuries, not a biography.
Q: “I’m finally allowing myself to dance to secular music. Why was I so afraid of this?”
(Asked by Leading Occasion)
The Heathen’s Take: I grew up in the 80s during the “Satanic Panic,” when we were told that if you spun a Judas Priest record backwards, you’d hear messages from the devil. (Which is ridiculous—who plays records backward?)
The idea that dancing or secular music is evil is bizarre. If you play music for a baby who can barely stand, they will start to bounce. It is a human instinct. Why would a God give humans a natural response to rhythm and then ban it?
If you are just now finding the freedom to enjoy music without fear of “catching the Holy Spirit” or being convicted by God, then good for you. Enjoy the music.
Q: “Why are most Satanists Goth or Alt?”
The Heathen’s Take: I have noticed this too. It feels like a costume.
It reminds me of growing up near Daytona Beach. Every year for Bike Week, thousands of bikers would ride in. They all claimed to be rugged individualists—rebels who didn’t follow society’s rules. Yet, if you looked at them, they were all wearing the exact same “uniform”: Harley shirt, denim vest, same bike.
They were conforming to a society of non-conformists. I see the same thing with modern Satanism. It’s often a group of people signaling their independence by wearing the exact same “goth” costume as everyone else in their group.
Q: “If God is all-knowing, didn’t he create people just to send them to hell?”
The Heathen’s Take: Yes, and this is where the logic of Christianity breaks down for me. You can’t have it both ways: you can’t say God knows the future perfectly (to the point of knitting you in the womb) but also claim you have free will.
If God creates a person knowing, with 100% certainty, that they will end up in hell, then what was the point of creating them?
It brings up the “Intelligent Design” argument. Believers say the eye is perfect proof of God. Well, tell that to me when I’m putting in my contacts. Tell that to someone whose body stops producing insulin. If I were designing a machine to worship me, I wouldn’t build it to break down, get cancer, and die. I’d make it indestructible. The fragility of human life doesn’t look like intelligent design; it looks like nature.
Q: “I’ve been deconstructing for 9 months, and my friends have left me. Any suggestions?”
(Asked by Ralph Humphreys)
The Heathen’s Take: Ralph, this is the hardest part. Believers often shun those who leave the fold to protect their own bubble. They treat atheism like a contagion.
My advice? Find your tribe. If you live in a small town, you might have to look toward the nearest big city or go online. The internet is a miracle for this—I have a friend in Dubai I talk to about camel meat who I will likely never meet in person, but we connected. You can find atheists the same way.
And here is the hard truth: If your friends dropped you solely because you changed your mind about God, they were never really your friends. You don’t need to waste your limited time on this planet stressing over people who don’t value you for you.
Visit us at www.Atheistville.com for more content from Mike Smithgall and the Atheistville team
📺 Subscribe on YouTube: youtube.com/@atheistville
💬 Want to be a guest or submit a question? Drop us a note at CONTACT
Check us out at: https://atheistville.buzzsprout.com
🔥 New episodes weekly from Atheistville — Mike Drop with Mike Smithgall, Ask an Atheist, and The Unholy Roundtable
© 2025 Atheistville Media
