Breakfast With A Heathen Ep2: How Religion Warps Politics, Parenting, and the Way We Think
Subscribe for updates: Leave this field empty if you're human: This Breakfast with a Heathen episode covers a range of questions from faith and politics to parenting and personal belief. We start with how religion was never out of U.S. politics—Trump only made it obvious—and look at what happens when faith becomes a tool for…
This Breakfast with a Heathen episode covers a range of questions from faith and politics to parenting and personal belief. We start with how religion was never out of U.S. politics—Trump only made it obvious—and look at what happens when faith becomes a tool for control rather than reflection.
We talk about the idea that atheists “believe in nothing,” the emotional damage of teaching children about hell, and the isolation that often follows when you stop believing. There’s a discussion about finding hope without faith, why you don’t need all the answers to live meaningfully, and how religion has traumatized people who once trusted it.
Lighter moments include alternative swear words, the ethics of infant baptism, and how to respond when someone says “God is science.” We also look at the claim that most Nobel Prize winners believed in God, and why historical context changes that picture.
It’s reason over rhetoric, curiosity over creed, and coffee over communion.
Here is the blog post draft based on the October 26, 2025 transcript. I have used the “Show Notes 2.0” format, incorporating your personal story about the Navy cup and the spool of wire as the intro hook.
Title Suggestion: “Why Not Be Gay?”, The “Cheese and Rice” Loophole, & When Republicans Lost Me (Breakfast with a Heathen)
Read the Q&A Highlights
Welcome back to another Breakfast with a Heathen. I’m drinking coffee out of my very worn-out “Navy Dad” cup today. I’ve had it for ten years, ever since my son joined the Navy. It has zero monetary value, but if my house were on fire, I’d grab this cup before the big-screen TV.
It reminds me of a video I saw of a man showing his wife a spool of wire he’d kept for decades. He used it for countless projects until only a few feet remained. He realized it wasn’t about the wire—it was about the life lived while using it.
That’s the vibe today: reflection. We’re covering everything from my past life as a Republican to the absurdity of “alternative swearing” and where atheists find hope without heaven.
Q: “Religion was never out of US politics. Trump just took off its mask.”
The Heathen’s Take: This is partly true. People assume I’ve always been a liberal, but I grew up a Republican. I voted for George Bush in ’88. I was pro-business, pro-military, and wanted smaller government.
But the party moved away from me. When the GOP was taken over by Evangelical values—becoming hostile toward LGBTQ rights and immigrants—they lost me.
Regarding Trump: I don’t blame him for creating the racism or bigotry in America, but I do blame him for emboldening it. I grew up in the South where people would whisper racist comments while looking over their shoulder. Now, thanks to the political climate of the last decade, people feel comfortable saying those things out loud.
Q: “So now that you believe in nothing, why not be gay?”
The Heathen’s Take: I assume this was asked tongue-in-cheek, but it reflects a common misconception: that without God, we have no boundaries or identity.
Why not be gay? Because I’m not. I’ve been married to my wife for 31 years and have always loved women. I couldn’t “turn” gay just because I stopped believing in God, any more than a gay man could “turn” straight because he started believing.
It’s like my favorite color. I love blue. If you told me God commanded me to wear green, I might wear green to stay out of hell, but I would still love blue. You can’t fake who you are.
Q: “Being an atheist is isolating.”
The Heathen’s Take: It absolutely can be. For many people, church isn’t just about belief—it’s their entire social structure. My mother is in her 70s, and almost everyone she knows is from her church. If she left, she would lose her community.
That is why finding a secular community is so important. We started an atheist group in Chicago ten years ago that began as a Facebook thread and turned into monthly meetups at a bar. You need to find your tribe—whether it’s fellow atheists, a hobby group, or a club. You have to replace that social network, or the isolation will win.
Q: “Have you ever thought about how messed up infant baptism is?”
The Heathen’s Take: Yes. I was raised Episcopalian and baptized as an infant, but looking back, it is strange. My mother and niece were baptized as adults in the Southern Baptist church, and honestly, that makes more sense to me.
At least as an adult or teenager, you can consent. You can say, “I understand this and I choose it.” Baptizing a baby who has no concept of what is happening feels more like a ritual for the parents than the child.
Q: “What do you think of alternative swearing?”
The Heathen’s Take: It’s ridiculous. My wife and I joke about people saying “Cheese and Rice” instead of Jesus Christ. Or “H-E-double-hockey-sticks.”
I saw a guy on Facebook say, “We’re having a heaven of a time” just to avoid the word hell. Come on. Do you think you are fooling God? If you smash your thumb with a hammer and yell “Dag-nabbit,” the sentiment is the same. You aren’t tricking the creator of the universe by changing a few vowels.
Q: “Where does hope come from now?”
The Heathen’s Take: My hope doesn’t come from what happens after I die. It comes from right now.
My daughter tells her young staff, “Make good choices.” It’s simple, but profound. My hope is based on the idea that if I make good choices—if I treat my wife and kids well, if I’m a good friend—then my life will be good now.
I don’t need a golden palace in the afterlife. I have a good life here. I have people who love me. When I die, it just stops, and I’m okay with that. The hope lies in making the time between birth and death count.
Q: “65% of Nobel Prize winners believed in God. Are you calling them liars?”
(Asked by Analogia Entis)
The Heathen’s Take: This is a classic correlation vs. causation error. Yes, between 1901 and 2000, many Nobel winners were religious. But they also lived in an era where everyone was religious.
Being smart at physics or literature doesn’t make you an expert on the existence of God. Great thinkers in ancient history believed in Zeus; that didn’t make Zeus real. If you look at modern scientists today, the numbers shift sharply toward non-belief. History reflects demographics, not divine proof.
