When Prayer Becomes Propaganda: The Rise of Christian Nationalism in Uniform
When Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth posted a video of himself reciting the Lord’s Prayer over military footage, ending with the words “Department of War,” it wasn’t faith, it was theater. This companion essay explores how Christian nationalism turns devotion into propaganda, why scripture contradicts it, and what history warns about when religion and state power fuse.
By Mike Smithgall | Oct 22, 2025 | Atheistville | Heathen Hotline: (224) 307-5435
A Prayer Wrapped in Power
A short video recently posted by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth shows him reciting the Lord’s Prayer over clips of military aircraft, soldiers in formation, and waving flags. It ends with a logo that reads “Department of War.”
It looks reverent. It sounds patriotic. But it’s neither.
This video isn’t about faith or prayer. It’s about using religion as a prop to sanctify political power. When a Cabinet Secretary turns one of Christianity’s most personal prayers into state imagery, that isn’t worship. It’s performance.
It signals something much deeper happening in American politics: the steady merging of Christianity with nationalism. The effect is to make military and political authority appear sacred. And that’s dangerous, both to democracy and to religion itself.
The Original Command: Prayer Should Be Private
The Lord’s Prayer comes from the Gospel of Matthew, chapter 6. But before the prayer itself, Jesus gives explicit instructions about how prayer should be done.
“And when thou prayest, thou shalt not be as the hypocrites are: for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and in the corners of the streets, that they may be seen of men. Verily I say unto you, they have their reward.
But thou, when thou prayest, enter into thy closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in secret; and thy Father which seeth in secret shall reward thee openly.” (Matthew 6:5–6, KJV)
Prayer, according to Jesus, is not supposed to be a public performance. It is an act of humility, not a show of devotion for the cameras.
When Hegseth uses that same prayer as the soundtrack for a military video, it turns sacred instruction into spectacle. The humility that Jesus emphasized becomes triumphalism. The Lord’s Prayer, placed at the heart of the Sermon on the Mount, was meant to promote peace, not power.
That sermon includes lines such as “Blessed are the meek” and “Blessed are the peacemakers.” (Matthew 5:5, 5:9) Those teachings run completely counter to the message of military dominance that Hegseth’s video presents.
This is the first sign of Christian nationalism at work: the rebranding of religious humility into national strength.
From Faith to Propaganda
This isn’t about one man’s faith. It’s about the calculated use of religious language to legitimize political agendas.
When officials frame government power as divinely sanctioned, it blurs the line between democracy and theocracy. That’s the essence of Christian nationalism, the belief that the United States was founded as, and should remain, a Christian nation. It’s not faith guiding politics. It’s politics wearing faith like a costume.
The repetition of “Department of War” instead of “Department of Defense” is another example of this strategy. Whether it’s an official change or just an informal slogan, the intent is clear: shift the public mindset from protection to aggression, while framing it as righteous.
In this context, prayer isn’t about spiritual reflection. It’s a performance of power. And when religion becomes performance, truth becomes secondary to spectacle.
The Formula of Christian Nationalism
Christian nationalism depends on symbols. The cross, the Bible, the flag, these are powerful emblems that evoke loyalty and emotion.
By combining them, politicians can turn faith into identity. Once faith becomes identity, it’s easier to define who belongs and who doesn’t. You’re not just patriotic, you’re part of God’s chosen nation. Everyone else becomes suspect.
That’s why videos like Hegseth’s matter. They reinforce the idea that real Americans are Christian Americans. They frame military strength as divine will. They make the cross and the gun appear to serve the same master.
But Christianity, at its core, teaches something very different. Jesus’ followers were told to love their enemies, to turn the other cheek, and to seek peace. Those values are impossible to reconcile with nationalistic aggression.
Using the Lord’s Prayer to bless the machinery of war strips it of meaning. It transforms faith into branding. And that branding serves power, not God.
The Warning From History

In 1935, Sinclair Lewis published It Can’t Happen Here, a novel that imagined an authoritarian American president who cloaks his ambitions in religion and patriotism. His fictional leader, Buzz Windrip, uses faith as theater. Lewis described his fake piety as “the blaring of a traveling salesman for church furniture.”
Every act of repression in the novel was justified “for the flag, for the country.” Lewis understood something we still struggle to face: authoritarianism doesn’t always arrive in jackboots. Sometimes it smiles, waves a Bible, and salutes the flag.
A quote often misattributed to Lewis summarizes his warning: “When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross.” Whether or not he said those exact words, the message stands.
Before Lewis, labor leader Eugene V. Debs said something similar: “Every robber or oppressor in history has wrapped himself in a cloak of patriotism or religion, or both.”
These warnings point to the same pattern. When leaders mix religious symbols with nationalism, it’s never about faith. It’s about control.
Who Gets Left Out
When a top government official posts a prayer video over military imagery, the question isn’t whether prayer belongs in public life. The question is: who gets included, and who doesn’t?
There are Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, atheist, and secular service members in the U.S. military. They serve with honor. They risk their lives. But when the Secretary of Defense posts a Christian prayer as a message of national unity, it sends an unmistakable signal: this military is Christian first, American second.
That message divides. It undermines the very idea of pluralism. It tells millions of Americans, many of whom have worn the same uniform, that their beliefs make them less patriotic.
Religious freedom doesn’t mean one tradition dominates the rest. It means none does. The founders understood that. It’s why the First Amendment begins not with what Congress should do, but what it must not do:
“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”
When officials use prayer to brand government authority, they are not exercising faith. They are establishing it. That’s a line no democracy can afford to cross.
The Illusion of Holiness
Christian nationalism thrives on spectacle because spectacle is easier to sell than principle. It gives people the illusion of moral certainty without the burden of moral complexity.
Genuine faith is quiet, reflective, and rooted in empathy. Propaganda is loud, performative, and built on fear. Hegseth’s video collapses the two into one. It treats the cross not as a moral guide but as a marketing logo.
The danger isn’t that religion exists in politics. The danger is when religion stops questioning power and starts serving it.
The Bible offers a clear counterexample. In Matthew 22:21, Jesus says, “Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.” That was a warning against fusing the state with divine authority. Yet here we are, nearly two thousand years later, watching leaders erase that line on purpose.
The more faith is used to decorate political messaging, the less influence it has to challenge it. What begins as devotion ends as propaganda. And once people stop noticing the difference, they become easier to control.
Reclaiming the Meaning
It’s tempting to dismiss videos like Hegseth’s as symbolic or harmless. But symbols shape culture. They define who we honor, who we fear, and who we trust.
If religion becomes a stage prop for the state, then both religion and democracy lose. One becomes hollow. The other becomes authoritarian.
That’s why it matters to push back, not against prayer itself, but against the distortion of it. When scripture is taken out of context to justify power, it needs to be called what it is: theater, not theology.
The Bible’s call to peace and humility still speaks. Matthew 5:9 says, “Blessed are the peacemakers: for they shall be called the children of God.”
No verse says, “Blessed are the warmakers.”
That contrast is the heart of the issue. When prayer becomes propaganda, peace becomes secondary. When religion blesses violence, faith loses its moral authority.
A Citizen’s Responsibility
You don’t need to be religious to see the danger. Every citizen who values democracy should care when leaders use religious imagery to justify force.
The merging of church and state doesn’t protect faith, it politicizes it. And once faith becomes political, it can no longer serve as a check on power.
Calling this out isn’t hostility toward religion. It’s defense of integrity. True belief doesn’t need a government logo to survive. It doesn’t need jets flying overhead to prove its strength.
Faith, if it has any meaning, is between the individual and their conscience. The moment it becomes a marketing tool, it loses the very soul it claims to protect.
Closing Thoughts
Pete Hegseth’s “Department of War” video was not a prayer. It was propaganda, an orchestrated blend of scripture, nationalism, and power. It turned devotion into display, humility into dominance, and faith into branding.
The Bible contradicts it. History warns against it. And democracy depends on rejecting it.
This isn’t about silencing religion. It’s about keeping religion honest and government accountable. When a nation’s symbols of faith and patriotism merge, authoritarianism no longer needs to announce itself. It arrives quietly, with a prayer on its lips and a flag in its hands.
👉 Watch the full Atheistville episode for the complete discussion, or listen to the podcast version wherever you get your shows. And if you found this valuable, share it, leave a comment, and keep the conversation going.
💬 Viewer Question
Do you think Christian nationalism is growing in the U.S., or are we only seeing it more clearly because of social media?
Mike Smithgall is the creator and host of Atheistville, a YouTube and podcast series exploring atheism, deconversion, and secular life through real conversation. He believes belief should be personal, not political, and uses Atheistville to connect people across faith and nonbelief through curiosity and respect.
YouTube | Website | Podcast | Heathen Hotline: (224) 307-5435
